I’ve finally gotten to see the 1st in the new epic trilogy. I went into the film with some reservations about it being too long and that what was a nice stand-alone book had been expanded into way too much. And then….well, it was this book long ago that got people interested into the Lord of the Rings, and for me was my gateway into Fantasy books. It was the first fantasy book I ever read – I devoured it in short order and later enjoyed the Record LP version of the story, including the animated movie. So with all that history, what did I think?
Well, the feel of middle earth that was seen in the Lord of the Rings trilogy is still well captured. Bag End, the Misty Mountains, the quick scenes of the Lonely Mountain. Great special effects as before and superb acting, including some good comedic timing in places, although also a bit lame in a few spots. I watched it in 2D, but you can see where the 3D parts would really show through. The “Riddles in the Dark” was superbly done, and was all that you would expect from that unique scene in the book. Gandalf plays that slightly humble wizard well when in the presence of his betters, and yet shows his intelligence and cunning quite well – so good acting there as well. So I really liked it, but….I found that despite the quick action that there were things which could have been left out on the editing room floor and the film would not be any worse for wear. I actually did check my watch at one point wondering how much longer I would sit. I feel slightly blasphemous for saying that I actually checked my watch, but for cripes sake, this is why such long epic films had an Intermission! So you can get up, stretch your legs, go to the bathroom, and return for the 2nd act. 2.75 hour marathons are amazing things to sit through, but dear lord it has to be perfect or you’ll tire, and I did. My only other slight complaint was that there were several places where the movie could have just ended – but it didn’t, and then went along into yet another scene. Again, my comment about too long I think, unfortunately, holds true here.
Oh well, this is a franchise that needs to make money and so I suppose there will be some flaws along the way towards that goal, and I saw some of them today. All that being said, I really enjoyed it and I would watch it again, but not all at once. Perhaps someday directors will remember the intermission and bring it back.